Santa Susanna is the former national church of the United States of America, as well as being an early 17th century monastic and titular church. It is on the Piazza San Bernardo, which is on the Via XX Settembre just north-west of the Piazza della Repubblica and its metro station. The postal address for the church is Via XX Settembre 15 for the church, and 14 for the monastery. These are in the rione Trevi. Pictures of the church on Wikimedia Commons are here. There is an English Wikipedia page here.
The dedication is to St Susanna, and the full official title is Santa Susanna alle Terme di Diocleziano.
THE CHURCH WAS CLOSED IN 2013 "FOR RESTORATION", AND IN 2018 WAS NOT EXPECTED TO REOPEN ANY TIME SOON. IT IS NO LONGER THE AMERICAN NATIONAL CHURCH.
The first Christian place of worship here possibly dated to the end of the 3rd century, and if so would have been a domus ecclessiae or a private house where a congregation assembled. The Christians of the period refrained from leaving any decorative or moveable elements identifying with their religion, so there has been no positive archaeological identification of such an institution in Rome. However a house of this period was excavated under the present church in the 19th century, and suggestively it aligns with the walls of the church above.
One tradition is that this was the titulus of Pope Caius (283–296). The tituli were the first parish churches in Rome, and this one was listed in a synod of 499 (the identification of this Caius with the pope is not entirely certain). An alternative tradition locates this titulus at the (now lost) church of San Caio nearby.
Titulus Sanctae SusannaeEdit
The Martyrology of Jerome, deriving from the end of the 6th century, has in its entry for 11 August: Romae, ad duas domos iuxta dioclecianas, natale Sce. Susanne. ("At Rome, at the two houses near the [Baths] of Diocletian, the martyrdom of St Susanna.") The name hints that the original place of worship was created from two private houses, and that Susanna might have been the proprietor or the patron of the worshipping community.
However the tradition grew up that she was a Roman virgin martyr, and a legend was written for her in the 6th century. This is romantic fiction, but in it Caius is mentioned as her uncle as well as Gabinus as her father. These references may be recalling the original householders. The church is claimed in the legend as the site of her martyrdom, and has been the centre of her veneration ever since.
The first mention of the titulus Sanctae Susannae is in a later synod of 595, when the titulus Gaii was not listed. This encourages the unprovable guess that the two were identical, but the existence of two separate tituli is entirely possible given the evidence.
The result was a T-shaped basilica, with a transept and an aisled nave with twelve columns in each arcade. Above the arcades were galleries for women, and behind the altar was an apse. This had a mosaic in its conch, showing the pope with the emperor Charlemagne and the epigraph: Dudum haec beatae Susannae martyris aula coangusto et tetro existens loco marmorato, quam Dominus Leo Papa Tertius a fundamentis erigens, et condens corpus Beatae Felicitatis martyris, compte aedificans ornavit atque dedicavit.
The Felicity mentioned is St Felicity of Rome, and there is a fresco concerning her in the sanctuary. The pope brought her relics here from her former basilica over the Catacombe di Massimo when those catacombs were abandoned.
The figures of pope and emperor had square haloes, indicating that they were alive when the work was executed.
After the 8th century, the city of Rome abandoned its hills which became mostly vineyards. The church was the only original building left on the Quirinal Hill, in a location so isolated as to be dangerous because of bandits.
It is mentioned in the Catalogue of Turin in c1320 as a titular church for a presbyterial cardinal, and was served by six clerics at the time. They almost certainly did not live there.
There was another rebuilding under Sixtus IV (1471-1484). The church was drastically cut down, with the aisles being demolished and the arcades walled up. The same thing was done to the nearby basilica of San Vitale, similarly lost in the countryside with little justification for its existence.
In 1587, Pope Sixtus V gave the church and an adjacent building to a new Cistercian community of nuns. This had been founded only the previous year by a Confraternity of St Bernard, attached to the church which is now Santissimo Nome di Maria al Foro Traiano.
Cardinal Girolamo Rusticucci had the church rebuilt yet again for them between 1593 and 1603. The architect was Carlo Maderno, and this commission established his career. The present building is the result.
The nunnery was so successful that it was able to found a daughter community at Nepi in 1618.
Oddly, the church was made parochial.
The nuns were expelled by the French under Napoleon between 1811 and 1814, but returned.
A major re-ordering of the parishes of the Centro Storico took place in 1824, under the bull Super Universam issued by Pope Leo XII. This suppressed the parish attached to the church, and the church of San Bernardo alle Terme across the way became the local parish church instead.
The nuns were again dispossessed by the Italian government after 1870, but were allowed to occupy a small portion of their original monastery.
In 1921, Pope Benedict XV authorised the setting up of the church as the national one for the United States of America. This was achieved in 1922 de facto (formally since 1924), and the Paulist Fathers were given the pastoral responsibility for this new function. Their official name is "Missionary Society of St Paul the Apostle", and they were founded in New York City.
In 1924, Cardinal Oreste Giorgi started a legal challenge against the government, claiming that the church and monastery originally belonged to the cardinalate and not the monastic community and hence that the seizure after 1870 was illegal. This challenge was successful, and full transfer of the property to the nuns was granted by Cardinal Richard Cushing in 1968.
Archaeological investigations at the end of the 19th century and in the 1930's were supplemented by interesting discoveries made in 1991.
The community of Cistercian nuns in the convent attached to the church is now only few in number, and in fact nowadays (2017) the Diocese only lists one resident. She is Sr Maria Assunta Cappiotti, described as Superiora e Legale Rappresentante.
The joint use of the church by the nuns and the Paulist Fathers did not work well, and trouble surfaced very soon after the nuns received formal ownership of the property in 1968. Before then, they were (in effect) tenants of the Cardinal and were probably not in a position to make a fuss.
Complaints by the nuns began quickly, concerning the level of noise and activity generated by the pastoral work of the Paulists for American expatriates and visitors. There was a serious breakdown of relationships in 1985, when the church was ordered closed because of a sag in the ceiling and because the electrical wiring was judged to be dangerous. The Paulists refused to vacate their accommodation attached to the closed church, and were actually ejected by the nuns in 1989. The latter prevailed because they are in the position of owning the property outright, and the Paulists found that their tenancy had not been properly legally secured in 1968.
A personal intervention by Pope St John Paul II was needed before the Paulists were allowed to resume work in 1993, which is when the church re-opened. Part of the agreement was that the Americans would not enter the convent and cloisters, and that the sacristy would be divided. The church was to be used on a time-share basis.
Another major restoration of the church was announced in 2013, and the church closed again. There was no immediate expectation that would will re-open. It seems that relationships have broken down once more, although information on exactly what is going on is not easy to come by.
Finally, in August 2017 the American expatriate community moved permanently to San Patrizio a Villa Ludovisi and so Santa Susanna is no longer the national church of the United States.
As at July 2018, it seems that the church is permanently closed down. One rumour is that a major issue concerns payment for the necessary restoration. Apparently the monastic community (or their representatives) have been arguing that the long tenancy by the Paulists incurred dilapidations which were neglected, and so they are partly responsible for the costs. Further, it is alleged that the tenancy agreement between the Cardinal and the Paulists, which was inherited by the nuns in 1968, did not make it properly clear as to how the costs of routine maintenance of the fabric, and of necessary interventions owing to depreciation, were to be divided.
The worst case scenario is that an unattended leaking roof causes the ceiling to collapse. Hopefully the Italian authorities make an emergency intervention before that happens.
The last titular of the church was Bernard Francis Law, who died in 2017. It is not expected that a replacement will be appointed until the church's future is sorted out.
Layout and fabricEdit
This church is short in length, with an unaisled nave of three bays, two large side-chapels flanking the triumphal arch and an almost square sanctuary with a semi-circular apse. There is no proper transept.
Behind the apse is the choir of the nuns, a separate although conjoined building not on the same major axis as the church. To the left of the apse is the campanile, which has a large arched sound-hole on each face and is crowned by a low onion-domed cupola.
Apart from the façade, the church is surrounded by other buildings but a good view of the exterior (including the campanile) can be had from the modern sculpture in the Largo Santa Susanna just to the north-east. This view also reveals that the façade is false, being much higher than the nave behind.
The convent was rather irregularly laid out, and never had a proper cloister. There is a garden between the church and an arcaded block running parallel to it to the west, but the main edifice is on the street to the left of the façade. This has a frontage in yellow brick.
This early and influential Baroque façade is by Carlo Maderno and was completed in 1603, five years before he started on the façade of San Pietro in Vaticano. It is considered his masterpiece.
It is in travertine and has two storeys, the lower with five vertical zones and the upper having three. These elements are arranged so that they point to the centre, this being done by their being slightly set back in turn. In other words, the façade is stepped vertically. The first storey has six attached Corinthian columns, four paired either side of the entrance where the façade sets back and the other two on the corner where it sets back again. The actual outer corners of the storey are marked by a pair of Corinthinan pilasters.
These columns and pilasters support an entablature the frieze of which has a Latin inscription: HIER[ONYMUS] EPIS[COPUS] PORT[UENSIS] CARD[INALIS] RUSTICUCIUS PAPAE VICAR[IUS] AD MDCIII ("Girolamo Rusticucci, Cardinal, Bishop of Porto and Papal Vicar, AD 1603"). This commemorates the cardinal of the church who oversaw the beginning of the building project, although he died in 1597 before the façade was begun.
The large entrance has a finely decorated doorcase, with a raised segmental pediment having a winged putto's head in its tympanum. This pediment is surrounded by volutes, swags of flowers and two more heads of putti and above the entablature is a second, triangular pediment. Beyond the paired columns on either side is a pair of statues in arched niches having their own triangular pediments; St Susanna is to the left, and St Felicity of Rome to the right. These statues are possibly by Stefano Maderno, although this is uncertain as is his relationship to the architect (traditionally they were brothers). The conchs of the niches have scallop-shell decoration.
The upper storey has six Composite pilasters corresponding to the columns below, and these support a blank entablature with a dentillate cornice and a crowning triangular pediment with a fine coat-of-arms in its tympanum. Unusually, the pediment gable is balustraded. In the centre of this upper storey is an arched balcony also with a balustrade. The arch of this has a tympanum with a sunrise motif, and is framed by a pair of swagged Ionic columns supporting a segmental pediment.
There is another pair of statues in this storey, above the pair mentioned, depicting St Caius and St Genesius. They are by Giovanni Antonio Paracca, nicknamed Il Valsoldo. Their niches are richly decorated with swags and putto's heads, and a playful detail is that their segmental pediments are broken and have tiny triangular pediments inserted.
The interior is also by Carlo Maderno, and is decorated in a bright late-Mannerist style. All the walls are covered by fresco paintings. The contrast with Maderno's Baroque work at Santa Maria della Vittoria, across the street to the east, is immense.
The unaisled nave has three bays, with a pair of large side chapels opening off the third one. The sanctuary is on an almost square plan, with a triumphal arch, and has an apse with a conch enclosed by its own arch.
The nuns' choir is behind the apse, but is invisible and inaccessible to visitors.
The nave has four Doric pilasters supporting statues on plinths, which depict the Major Prophets Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel and Daniel. These are by Giovanni Antonio Paracca, Il Valsoldo.
The six paintings concerning the Old Testament Susanna on the side walls are by Baldassare Croce. According to the story she was a Jewish woman who was a victim of false charges of impurity, but who was saved by the prophet Daniel.
The flat wooden ceiling of the nave is attributed also to Baldassare Croce. It is finely carved, coffered and gilded and features Our Lady with the Rusticucci coat-of-arms. The design is thought to have been by Maderno.
The sanctuary is raised above a confessio or devotional crypt, the entrance to which is protected by a D-shaped balustrade with the semi-circular portion intruding into the nave. The frescoes in the apse depicting scenes from the legendary life of St Susanna are by Cesare Nebbia. To the left she is being accosted by Maximian the son of the emperor Diocletian, with an angel intervening, and to the right she is refusing to sacrifice to idols. The four panels in the apse show her Apotheosis; she is in the middle, angels with period 16th century instruments flank her and Christ holding a crown is waiting at the top.
The stucco decoration was by Matteo Zoccolini, who was a Theatine priest. It involves garlands, fruit, scrollwork and little putti all gilded. Flanking the pilasters of the apse arch are two statues by Paracca, of SS Peter and Paul, with doors beneath leading into the nuns' choir
The aedicule of the altar is against the far wall of the apse. It has two Ionic columns of green marble supporting a split triangular pediment the fragments of which enclose two angels holding a cross. The altarpiece depicts the Decapitation of St Susanna, and is by Tommaso Laureti. Below it you can see a grille, and this is here so that the nuns could attend to Mass being said on the altar.
The left wall of the presbyterium has a large fresco of the Martyrdom of St Gabinius by Croce, and the corresponding one on the right wall shows the Martyrdom of St Felicity and her Seven Sons which is by Paris Nogari.
Chapel of St LawrenceEdit
The Chapel of St Lawrence is the one on the left. It is also known as the Cappella Peretti.
In the chapel to the left are enshrined the relics of St Genesius of Arles, also known as Genesius the Comedian, who was a martyr and is the patron saint of actors. The picture of the Baptism of St Genesius is by Croce again. To the right is a shrine to Pope St Eleutherius (175-189) . His body was moved from San Giovanni della Pigna by Camilla Peretti, Pope Sixtus V's sister, in 1591 after she commissioned the chapel. The fresco depicting him is by Pozzo. It shows the pope being dragged by horses and burned over a grill while Emperor Commodus watches.
St Felicity and one of her seven martyred sons are also enshrined here, under the altar. Their relics were brought to safety from the Catacombs of Maximus on the Via Salaria by Pope Leo when he rebuilt the church. These catacombs were also named after her, and are somewhere around the junction of the Via Salaria and the Via Metauro.
Chapel of Our Lady of GracesEdit
The chapel to the right is dedicated to Our Lady of Graces, and has two modern frescoes depicting St Benedict and St Bernard as patrons of the Cistercian order. These replaced two pictures by Avanzino Nucci now in the choir.
The icon is one of several copies in Roman churches of an ancient original which used to be at Santa Maria della Consolazione before it was stolen.
The nuns' choir, which was built with the church in 1597, is behind the main altar. It is an ample rectangular room with a flat coffered wooden ceiling of the period, bearing the coat-of-arms of Cardinal Rusticucci. The choir stalls were provided by Pope Pius V, and the ensemble is considered one of the best surviving conventual choirs in Rome.
The wall-frescoes by Francesco Mezzetti (1676-1702) depict scenes from the Old Testament. Also here are four depictions by Nucci of SS Benedict, Bernard, Susanna and Scholastica (the first two already mentioned above).
Fresco in a sarcophagusEdit
Excavations took place under the nuns' sacristy in 1991, in an area corresponding to the left hand nave aisle of the Leonine basilica. The most important discovery was a 2nd century sarcophagus containing the skeleton of a man, on which layers of detached fresco painting had been carefully placed. The style dates the work to the late 8th century, hence it would have been executed during the restoration ordered by Pope Adrian I. Why it was treated in the way that it was after the Leonine restoration is a mystery.
The restoration of this has been prolonged, but the result is viewable in the sacristy (before the church was closed this was open on application 9:30-11:30 and 16:00 to 16:45, although this will probably change since it depends on a nun being free to supervise).
The main scene is pentagonal, with a gable. It depicts the Madonna and Child flanked by two female saints, identified as Agatha and possibly Susanna. The top side corners contain SS John the Baptist and John the Evangelist, and the gable has the Lamb of God flanked by two Gospel quotations in Latin on a blue background: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God" (St John the Evangelist), and "Behold the Lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world" (St John the Baptist).
Fragments of four other portraits of saints were also recovered.
The excavation, with the sarcophagus in situ, has been left open and is protected by a glass floor.
THE CHURCH IS CLOSED FOR "RESTORATION" (2019) WITHOUT ANY FIXED DATE FOR REOPENING.
The word is that the closure is, de facto, permanent. No restoration work is going on.
2019: NO LITURGICAL ACTIVITY.
Before 2013 the church had two functions, as a monastic church and as a national church. It has lost the latter, and does not function as the former.
BEWARE OF A MALWARE PHISHING PAGE USING THE "santasusanna.it" DOMAIN.
Official diocesan web-page (Not updated to accommodate recent events. One wonders why.)
Convent's website (Defunct, which is not a surprise.)
|Argentina | Armenia I | Armenia II | Belgium | Canada | Croatia | Denmark | Ethiopia I | Ethiopia II | France | Germany | Greece | Hungary | Ireland I | Ireland II | Italy/Calabria | Italy/Camerino | Italy/Lombardy | Italy/Lucca | The Lebanon | Mexico | The Netherlands | Norway | The Philippines | Poland | Portugal | Romania | Russia | Spain | Sweden | Syria | Ukraine I | Ukraine II | Ukraine III | United Kingdom | United States|